Wanted to like this so much since jumping on the Milk bandwagon, but unfortunately it just really isn't worth it. Not waterproof or long lasting, does nothing impressive for the lashes (no extra length or volume), bottle is very heavy and just not easy to use at all. Really disappointed and wish I could get my money back!

Like many others, I bought this thinking it would be great for summer as it’s waterproof... Turns out even when it’s not rainy it smudges so I’m very disappointed with my purchase.

It’s lively and lengthening BUT it’s not waterproof!!!! I work in outdoor events and so am outside a lot and before I knew it, the mascara was down my face making me look like a horror movie... So much so that I had to go and wash my whole face as it was everywhere. How has this been called waterproof?? I’m a fan of Milk but this was an overhyped mess...

I wanted to get a good waterproof mascara for when I started swimming in the summer so I can just go straight from work. The original formula of this mascara is good at first but I found it was flaky and would smudge on my eyelids and browbone as the day went on. The waterproof formula is slightly better but not much of an improvement. It does last fairly well on the lashes but still has the tendency to flake off and smudge so I'd say it's more splash proof than waterproof. Wouldn't buy again!

Not very impressed. I'm no mascara connoisseur and usually buy cheaper brands. I took a chance and paid more than I would have liked to for this mascara based on it being waterproof. Day 1 of using it something bad happened and I had a little cry, looked in the mirror and I may as well have used a cheaper alternative. For something that's supposed to be waterproof, there was little to no product left on my lashes and black streaks all down my face. I've seen cheaper non-waterproof mascaras leak less than this! Honestly not happy with any aspect of this mascara - it's overpriced, NOT waterproof and even the wand is disappointing as it does nothing for length or volume. Honestly, I'd have been just as disappointed if I'd paid £5 for it.

Bought this waterproof Kush mascara as a more eco friendly alternative to my regular mascara and it goes on beautifully but it doesn’t stay on. I get those dark circles under my eyes which I usually get with non-waterproof, cheap mascaras, and if I cry (usually when I laugh, don’t worry) it runs everywhere. I think if I’d bought the regular mascara I’d expect this but being waterproof I had hoped for more staying power :(

It’s a very wet formula at first - it tends to need a second layer to get a fuller, thicker effect. It works a lot better as the formula starts to dry out.

To be honest, this mascara looks fine when it first goes on. It is separating, not clumpy, which I like. But I was expecting it to be more lengthening, as it is advertised as having "hollow heart-shaped fibres that cling to individual lashes", and I have to say I noticed no discernible lengthening effect. As fibre mascaras go, the Glossier Lash Slick is far superior. My main issue with this mascara though is that it is not actually waterproof. I don't have especially greasy lids, but after just a few hours I look like a panda. I have non-waterproof mascaras that smudge less than this one. For how expensive this is, it is really not worth it.

Having read the mixed reviews on the original formula of this product I decided to give the waterproof version ago in the hope that a waterproof formula would correct some of the issues with the normal version. Although I didn't get any of the smudging a lot of people mention with the original this does still drop little black specks on your face and fades away on the tips of your lashes as the day goes on. Didn't think that the it created great lashes either. I've stopped using it after 3 uses and re-ordered the Hourglass Caution, which is a much better allrounder.

Amazing product. Never had a mascara feel like it glides on like silk like this one does. So smooth to apply, gets all the lashes and give the most amazing look! So glad I tried this, it's defo my new staple product! 20/10 for this one!