This one is truly worth the money! Spreads like butter and does not move once it’s fully dry.

These eyeliners are all beautiful. I bought 4.  Chestnut is a very unique brown-red that I’ve never seen before. I love how elegant and sleek the line looks like. The only downside is that the line dries very fast. 

I’m obsessed with this eyeliner! This is the 3rd I purchase and I’m eyeing a 4th one…Chestnut is such a beautiful colour for green or hazel eyes. It’s s very unique shade of red-brown, very natural and perfect for fall looks. 

My daughter introduced me to this line of gel eyeliners and got me hooked. Everything about this product is luxurious, from the packaging, through the way it applies, to the way it looks and lasts.  Worth the splurge. I have brown eyes and my favorite shade is 'Forest'.

This is my first repurchase of cave snd I bought all the shades after trying the first one. I adore how buttery this eyeliner is and how easy it is to apply. It’s so beautiful that I often use it on its own with no eyeshadow. It’s waterproof and it stays on the whole day. I might reapply when going out at night after a long day. It works for the waterline too snd had never caused me any irritation like unfortunately numerous other do.

After Forest being my new favorite, I wanted more of this elegance. Although I have more than one brown, Cave has immediately become the most used. It has a beautiful depth to it and I’m all for its shine without shimmer.  And there’s no other eyeliner that is so creamy. It’s very easy to apply.  It dries a bit too fast for me but it stays the whole day where it’s supposed to and I love it. If you think it’s a bit pricey, don’t worry. You won’t be thinking about it after the first application as it’s just gorgeous!

A beautiful and unique green that when applied lightly looks more like a moss green and still keeps this shade when blended out but if applied stronger becomes more of a crocodile and even juniper than forest.  It’s creamy and glides on the skin effortlessly. The final look is very special. It looks like velvet and has s shine to it without any shimmer that looks elegant. Being retractable there’s no need to sharpen it and if a more pointed tip is needed, one can form it with a finger, a Kleenex or very fine sandpaper/paper nail file in 5 seconds.  It stays on for the whole day and can be used in the waterline. It looks beautiful, classy and besides the price there’s nothing not to love about it. Will be coming back for other shades for sure.

It came broken, and CB helped me with the problem, but also, I didn't like the color, too dark. It was broken because someone first rotated the bottom mechanism that wasn't closed that I checked, so the the stick was pulled up and ofc broke. I am sure it is a nice quality but the color is very dark

I bought the colour cave in this and I absolutely love it. Easily blendable but doesn't budge throughout the day.

This’s going to be the only eyeliner pencil I’ll buy forever! Expensive comparatively but worth the price