It is a good mascara, but nothing too special in terms of effect. It lengthens and curves the eye lashes nicely and it is very easy to remove with just warm water (but I use cleanser+warm water most of the time). The packaging is heavy and feels luxurious, it is a nice present for makeup lover. One thing I've noticed is that this mascara is not water-proof and I get panda eyes when it rains or snows, something I don't always have with other tubing mascaras.

I have oily eyelids and most mascaras smudge terribly on me. I haven't had the best of luck with tubing mascara either but this one is the rare exception. I love that it comes with a plastic wand. It stays put on my lashes, is water-resistant and can be removed easily enough. I never want to be without.

Best mascara I ve ever tried! And it is so easy to remove. Expensive, but worth it, especially because it lasts a realy long time even though I ise it daily

I previously have used the Caution Mascara from Hourglass and thoroughly enjoyed it. When this came out, I thought I'd give it a try and I'm so happy I have. Excellent mascara with superb staying power - stays on until I need to take it off as it is a tubing (polymer) based mascara. Comes off easily as well. Lasts through a good cry or two without making me look like a panda. Goes on easily and really creates length. I use revitalash (also excellent and available via Cult) to maintain the length of my natural lashes and this only helps create a false lash/long lash effect. I've been asked whether I wear extensions and I don't. Gives you a natural extended looks and doesn't clump.

This is my holy grail mascara and I'll continue to repurchase! the price tag is hefty for a mascara but a single tube lasts me around 6 months with everyday use. Doesn't flake and comes off easily with warm water

Never ever had a mascara like this! The best! Ever! Creates great lengthes and volume! Love it

I have very thin lashes they look bold. But they're naturally curled although not very long and not super dense. With good mascara my lashes can look pretty great considering the alternative. My favourites have always been Lancome Monsieur Big and Essence Lash Princess in green tube to give me thick, long, dark, fluttery lashes. But since I discovered Kiehl's eye cream which finally helps my super dry undereyes without burning the skin, as well as hydrating concealers, everything smudges. Even waterproof ones because my under eyes are now actually not dry. The plastic bristles wand is not super amazing at separating and the formula is rather thin. I can't build it up too much without looking clumpy but it's not the best in lengthening and volumising. It's good, but not amazing. It's great for simpler makeup days but won't give you dramatic lashes. Unfortunately it's the only thing that does not smudge on me.

I’m now purchasing my third tube of this mascara and it’s the best I’ve ever used! A true black, no smudging, no crumbling and no spider looking lashes. This is the only mascara for me that lengthens, adds volume and separates the lashes - obsessed! 

I bought this mascara after reading rave reviews - it’s a brand new tube, and by 10am my mascara crumbles down my face. I have to clear it up but a couple of hours later there’s more. Then a couple of hours later, more.Absolutely dreadful product - what a waste of money 

Second time buying this, it’s absolutely te best for me. Never smudges and I love the look it gives.