While the quality is definitely there, I’m disappointed. For years I heard and read about how wonderful the original was and it was even called the best mascara. Since I only use brown mascaras, I jumped on it as soon as it came out. I couldn’t wait to try it out. Well, it’s not as wonderful as I was told. I don’t really see anything that special about it.  I love the packaging and how heavy it is. The color is a beautiful dark brown. My problem is the brush that is way too big. I touch my my inner corner each time, no matter how careful I am. It also doesn’t look too natural. And on the tips of the lashes form some cloths quite often.  I find it also not as long lasting as my other mascaras and find sone smudges under my eyes after a long day or if it’s hot outside.  It’s either not the best mascara out there if it’s just not for me. 

I really like this mascara. Sometimes brown colors end up not brightening my eyes enough, but this is a rich brown. It stays on well, doesn’t clump during application, and washes off easily with regular cleanser.

Absolutely stunned by this mascara. I absolutely love the brown, because black makes my face look so mean and the colour brown really lifts me up and makes my eyes look more kind. I’m an absolute fan and will be buying this again!

Great colour, lashes are super soft and not flakey and provides great length and is build able for volume!

I tried it in the past and wasn’t really happy with it (in black), for some unknown reason I’ve decided to buy it again, this time in brown. Color is great (dark, deep brown), but mascara leaves big chunks on my eyelashes and smudges under eyes 

This is the best brown mascara i have ever used the shade of brown is so pretty and the mascara is very lengthening and gives good volume

Love the colour, leaves lashes super soft and doesn't flake. Highly recommend!

The wand is perfect for creating long but natural looking lashes. Would reccomend

This mascara is so nice, and brown color makes it even better j would say!

This is my first Too faced BTS mascara. I love love love the rich brown colour. It is dark enough, but much softer than black mascaras. I think I will never buy black mascara again. The only downside in my case is that it still transfers on my lower eyelid, although less than other mascaras.