I have been using benefit eye liner from a while now. But ordered from cult first time. It was literally dry. Normally benefit eye liner lasts for months. So disappointed.

I have tried a lot of eyeliners and this is by far my favorite. Very smooth application, stays all day and generally love it!

I got this eyeliner a few weeks ago and I have tried it so many times to see if I can maybe find some use for it but I really hate it and I am very annoyed how much I paid for it cos it is gonna go in the bin. I generally don't like felt tip liners but I like Benefit and wanted a brown liner so I thought I'd try. I also I recently bought Too Faced Better Than Sex eyeliner which is the best ever liner I have used so I thought its similar well not even close. My skin is a bit loose around my eyes and it is just very hard to make a thin straight line with it, it really drags and make my eyes water as the ink just doesn't seem to come out very easily unless I apply pressure. It is impossible to make a nice sharp wing as the thin part of the felt tip does absolutely nothing. No ink comes out unless you put lots of pressure then your thin line is ruined. It also smudged after about 8 hrs wear and I am very careful not to touch. This is a very badly designed product. I got a Bourjois liquid liner in brown instead which is much better.

I have been using this since it launched, and I use it almost every day. Such a good eyeliner; the tip is thin and very workable. It's black and dries matte, too. It doesn't seep or run. Literally lasts on my eyes for 16 hours. Before this, I use to use to Kat Von D tattoo liner, but the roller liner has become my OG.

So worth the money! I love this eyeliner, it’s beautifully matte and black, and it goes on smooth and easily. Highly impressed and I’ll definitely be repurchasing.