The wand is too big and it is hard to put on mascara without putting it on the lids

Either I got old dry item, or this mascara really sucks. Glued my eyelashes together in 3.

I so wanted to love this. The first one I had delivered was a completely empty tube, but customer service sorted it out straight away. It’s replacement was clumpy, went all over my eye as the brush was so big, and within 2 hours had smudged everywhere. I did like I always do with disappointing mascaras and put it away for a month as they’re sometimes better after a while, tried it again and it was as dry as a bone. My very last foray into Too Faced.

Brush is too big to me, but for those who like a big one, will be perfect.

Firstly let me say I’m only giving this 4 stars and not 5 because I hate the size of the wand, it’s unnecessarily huge and I don’t think it makes a real difference to application. Because it’s so big it’s almost impossible not to get mascara on your lid but if you can deal with that then GOOD LORD IS THIS SOME VOODOO. The whipped formula is truly phenomenal, this is my fave mascara of all time. I have REALLY oily eyes but this is the only mascara to have not transferred onto my upper and lower eyelids, and I’ve tried so many from Benefit, etc. It makes me look like I’m wearing falsies without looking clumpy/spidery or flaking off during the day. The whipped formula makes my lashes look freshly curled all day, and I love curling my lashes after applying this mascara (I know you’re not supposed to but whatever) to make them look dramatic. Honestly the best, if you have oily skin you NEED this.

This is my new favourite mascara. It volumizes, lengthens and gives a bit of lift. I do however wish that the "funnel" at the top was a bit tighter, because I think this one is prone to drying out as well as leaving way too much product on the brush. Also, not tear-proof. Will repurchase in spite of this, because it's the best I've found.

Although this looked lovely on my lashes, it didn't have any staying power and within a couple of hours I had panda eyes. I thought it was meant to be long lasting.

Heard SUCH good things about this mascara but it literally makes my lashes poker straight. The brush is enormous so I find it quite hard to apply, and yes it does make my lashes thick and I don't think it flaked or smudged, but I don't want horizontal lashes, so it's a no from me.

Thought I would give this a go as no matter what mascara I use, they all smudge and flake. Zero flaking and lashes stay nice and soft but this still does smudge a little. Nothing like previous mascaras I've tried but not quite 100% smudge free. Wand also takes some getting used to as it's quite large but overall a good mascara.

This is absolutely THE BEST mascara EVER created! I just got it 2 weeks ago, after seeing that my favourite brand, Too Faced, launched it on the market and I had to try it out. My natural lashes are so small, can barely see them, even with mascara on, but this one plumps them like no other. You don’t have to apply a lot and bam! Full, black lashes! I love it!