I love the colours, ease & longevity of these. I did not give 5 stars because the stick often flies out when I take the lid off. This happens on all the colours I have unfortunately. 

This product is very convenient which is why I keep reaching for it. With that said, the pigment does tend to fade quite quickly when you blend it and you are left with just sparkle. I can make it work by layering but I can imagine there are better versions of this product on the market. 

I love the shades and the original Eye Wands, so ordered three shades as soon as they launched. One was immediately damaged, as other reviews describe and the other two have since also fallen out after little use. Whilst they were working, I was disappointed in the longevity of the shadows and find the shimmer gathers in creases; they seem rather different to the original Eye Wands, which last really well. I feel these were sold before the formula was right, not up to the usual Vieve standard.

I absolutely love Jamie and have followed her for years. The Matte eye wands are amazing and I wouldn’t be without them however these are nothing like as good and I also received one colour that the whole stick fell out of the component. 

Bought because I thought the shade was appealing, but I had the same problem as another reviewer where the whole stick fell out of the applicator. Easy to fix but disappointing that it happened. I find that it isn’t shimmery, more a sparse glitter effect. Won’t repurchase, probably won’t use much at all unfortunately. Will stick with BB or LM.