Very nice and easy to use eyeliner; never smudged on me, lasted me a very long time even though I used it every day and the felt tip remained in perfect shape until I finished it

This is the best eyeliner I have ever used. It is a intense black, easy to use, nice precision but not too thin so I work very effectively, it does not transfer to my eye lids, which for me it is always a problem (I have hooded eyes). It would be my HG . Buuuut, after trying one in the advent calender, I reordered. One was quite dry and I had to stop using it very quickly. I ordered another one and it leaks, I can still use it, but I have to be very careful and it's annoying. Not sure if I will order again, I love it but it does not have to have quality consistency :(.

Extremely wet and kinda glossy eyeliner. Easy to smudge, hard to apply, transfers quickly. Easy to remove, thankfully.

This Natasha Denona liquid liner is the best eyeliner i have ever used. The reason why is simple, it does not dry up or fade like so many other eyeliners on the market. It does not run either. This for me is key, eyeliners i have bought in the past tend to last a a few weeks and the stop working. I am using this one 6 weeks and its going strong-highly recommend it.

I have been using a cheaper eyeliner but decided to splurge out and buy this based on positive reviews. The results are disappointing. This liner has a fibre tip, so it doesn’t draw a very fine line. In fact, I find this rather clumsy compared to brush tip liners I’ve used which by comparison draw a neater, more controlled, finer stroke. Perhaps I ought to have checked this before purchasing. However, this liner also leaks badly each time I use it making me wonder how long it will last!  Really disappointing given this is priced at the higher end of the spectrum for liquid liners. On the plus side the formulation is amazing. A true black pigment that stays put, but it’s just not worth the cost, not when there are equally good products available at just a third of the price.