That's the first ever eye I got from NARS, and I am blown away - glides like butter, super long lasting even when not set with powder eye shadow, and doesn't transfer on the water line when tight lining the upper lash line. Not to mention the shade Mambo, which is just spectacular - I am very fair, and as black tends to look a bit too aggressive for daytime, I always look for a nice brown shade, and this is the most beautiful one out there.

I got the beautiful midnight blue shade, but I am very disappointed with this liner since I really like all the other Nars products that I have. It is very crumbly when I apply it, almost impossible to smudge it out. Perhaps the other colors have better texture but I won't be buying again.

I have the shade mambo and just love it

I really like the colour but it’s make my eye tears 

I got in "Park Avenue" which is a nice dark blue. It glides easily and is comfortable but smudges terribly.