Just starting off I have to say the packaging is so aesthetically pleasing! Feels like a luxury product straight away. This mascara gave me ridiculously long eyelashes, however, I did have to work with it quite a while and apply a fair few coats. I gave it four stars as I'd have preferred a little more volume, but my usual mascara is too faced better than sex, so I find that hard to complete with any mascaras.

Wanted to love this and so looked forward to receiving it. Huge disappointment - wet and clumpy. Have to say hugely disappointed with all the milk cosmetics.

I can't make my mind up about this mascara. I love the idea that it nourishes lashes and I like how it looks when I want a really suitable (no makeup makeup) look. However, I tried to build it up and it clumped together so much so that it flaked off. By the end of the day I had loads of black speckles all over my face. I think with this one, its more for those natural days rather than dramatic lashes. I will need to keep testing to really make up my mind.

I was really excited to try this out and on first application was blown away. It made my eyelashes stand out and look so lovely and long, held a curl and immediately text a friend a picture showing the difference! However, by the end of the day it had smudged all down my eyes! I love this mascara but can't deal with the panda look. I will try layering something over the top to hopefully help it stay in place but I don't have high hopes.

So, it's not that its a BAD mascara it's just not that great compared to others and is a bit messy. The wand itself is chunky and when putting it back into the tube it clunks up at the top, I've had it a week now and I've had to clean it twice. The lashes look long and thick, you can see quite a difference and the lashes look good and would be good if going out for a couple hours. This wear though on me only lasts about 5 hours, after it tends to smudge a bit under my eyes especially as I put it on my lower lashes or I get flakes under my eyes or on my glasses. So overall i'm a bit disappointed, I won't be purchasing again as it doesn't work for me.