I‘m a big fan of cleansing balms, I have tried many cheap and expensive, luxurious and functional....This for me is not a cleansing balm. Would imagine myself using it as a mask maybe, nothing else.I have tried it with and without makeup. It is super difficult to spread, doesn‘t melt at all, so Spreading it over your face is not a nice experience at all. Once I had a bit of mascara (not waterproof) and it didn‘t remove it, trying to remove it with this „balm“ was awful and had to remove it with another product afterwards.Also, once you remove the balm (either with water or cloth) ir‘s super difficult to get rid of some little particles.So, for me, not effective, not sensorial, not a nice cöeansing experience at all. It‘s the first time I write a negative feedback but I had to say it.