I like the liquid liner. But it is a crime to remove it. The kohl side is very hard and no way you can line your eyes. But overal the liquid version is fine. I can create very intense eyes. That i like.

i liked the liquid eyeliner but when it comes to remove it.. i tried wipes, oil cleaner, balm remover. the other side became dry so quickly and fragile

When this launched Huda raved about how much effort they spent perfecting the formula. I've worn liquid liner for the last 30 years. This seemed to tick all the boxes. Lasts, intense color payoff, and a brush for application! Was very disappointed. The handle is uncomfortable to hold during application. The brush is too short and stubby to give you the control you need to make a cat eye. It doesn't last. It is easy to remove. It doesn't sit well over Huda metallic shadows. And there is very little product in the container (mine was used up after ten applications). Normal liner on other end is nothing special. It doesn't stay put in the waterline and isn't very black.