I love the tingle and cooling effect this has! I also find it really hydrating unlike other similar products that leave your lips super dry feeling after it comes off. 

I love the feeling and how it makes my lips look bigger but still classy. 

I like the color it gives and the sensation of cold, but i see no plumping effect.

This is my second tube, and I will repurchase for sure. makes lips fuller and more hydrated. Ideal before foundation etc, as a base for lipstick

I bought both lip plumpers and have to say if you can’t choose definitely go with the spicy, it’s more lip plumping. Like Huda suggested she uses the icy before she goes to bed and I’ve been doing the same and I wake up with soft lips so it works well as a treatment but for the more plumping effect the spicy is the one :)