I’m now purchasing my third tube of this mascara and it’s the best I’ve ever used! A true black, no smudging, no crumbling and no spider looking lashes. This is the only mascara for me that lengthens, adds volume and separates the lashes - obsessed! 

I bought this mascara after reading rave reviews - it’s a brand new tube, and by 10am my mascara crumbles down my face. I have to clear it up but a couple of hours later there’s more. Then a couple of hours later, more.Absolutely dreadful product - what a waste of money 

Second time buying this, it’s absolutely te best for me. Never smudges and I love the look it gives. 

I read a number of glowing reviews of this mascara,but my experience was very disappointing.I would say I have an average length, average thickness lashes. Most mascaras work reasonably well for me. This mascara created a very weird look-I ended up with what looks like 3 Long eyelashes with no extra volume whatsoever. When I tried to layer it my lashes just clamped together.On the positive side it smells nice and reasonably easy to remove. Performance however is very poor in my opinion

I really do enjoy this mascara, it covers my lashes evenly, plus it lengthens and adds volume. I go back to it time after time, even after trying numerous others. I have an issue with trying mascara's, they are the product I love to experiment with. I find this lasts all day and is so easy to remove. I don't know why others don't get along with this mascara, but I'm guessing others love some that I hate. I am a fan of tubing mascara's though. I also love Le Volume De Chanel mascara for an added punch despite it not being a tubing mascara.