I tried the waterproof one first but it was so difficult to get off I used to wake up with leftovers the next day so I tried this one - it's good but not the best I have had - would I buy again - yes

This mascara resist really week to the heat but it was nothing so amazing

it does what it says (waterproof even when I was 3 hours on the beach and in the water). But on the downside it is also very difficult to remove. does not clump and works really well.

I have been searching for a good waterproof mascara that isn't gloopy on application and withstands eye drops being administered. This one (Tears in rain) is perfection!The formulation coats every lash, lengthening and defining my fairly short lashes and does not clog up. It doesn't smudge or leave me with panda eyes at the end of the day.The packaging is also really nice, it feels like a treat to use every day! Remove with an oil based or two phase eye make up remover.

I think I'm obsessed with this mascara. The formulation, the brush, the packaging are all truly fabulous. This mascara coats the lashes evenly, lengthens and provides subtle volume but my absolute favourite things about this guy is the perfect amount of product is distributed on the brush from first use which NEVER happens. It's a pleasure to use, is long lasting, lightweight yet packs a beautiful deep black punch. Buy it, you won't regret it! I'm off to try Astronomical because in my opinion nobody does it better than Byredo.