So sorry I had not read reviews on this product. Ordered as I’ve used bare minerals in the past .v difficult to apply Eyelashes clump and mascara smudges almost immediately would not recommend.

Being completely and utterly devoted to my one and only Holy Grail mascara I rarely hold out much hope that anything else will rival it... yet the day this graced my lashes was a very good day indeed!What most caught my attention was the ability this has to hold a curl. I usually have to layer primer with my usual mascara to get a decent hold on my straighter-than-straight stubborn lashes, but this honestly held all day long. Even my oily eyelids didn't turn into panda eyes until the very end of the day (and only with a tiny bit of smudge!). For a natural, defined look this is a gorgeous go-to for every day but if you're all about the volume I'd look to another formula.

I find the formula quite thin & it doesn't really do anything for my lashes compared to other mascaras I've used. Not worth the expense personally

Wanted to love this, it goes on nicely but it smudges within minutes. I am very careful with my eyes, I don't rub them or touch them, I don't wear glasses and I don't have watery eyes, so there is no reason why this should have smudges so quickly. I tried using different eye creams, waiting over an hour between skin care and mascara etc, but every single time it smudged very quickly. It's going straight in the bin.