Like the product. But it's not as waterproof as cliniques eyeliner for example.

Very good liner from a very good brand. Unfortunately, it went quickly given the small amount. Highly recommended for those who often use a liner and are good at it.

Perfect and easy to apply, stays all day and never smudges. Washes off easily,Its also easy to apply since the tip is thin and long.Will purchase again.

I've been using this product for over a month now and I'm super impressed by the actually product.It's very pigmented, dries quickly and does not smudge or flake at all. After working a 12 hour day this liner looks the same as when I put it on which I love. It's also easy to remove as it's not waterproof but stays on like a waterproof product.My issue is with the applicator. The brush is not as fine as it looks in the photo and because the end is quite soft and spongy, it can be very difficult to make a fine line. Also it sometimes seems to hold on to the product so you have to dip it repeatedly. If they changed the applicator to a fine brush rather than a felt tip style I think this would be unbeatable.

I made a compromise with this brand and it appeared to be delusional when it is about this eyeliner. The very thick application remains matte and does not provide fine lines.