I was so disappointed by this mascara. I love Sunday Riley skincare, so I had high hopes. But this is one of the worst mascaras I've tried in ages. It goes everywhere it shouldn't - I get smudges all along the edge of my eyelid, messing up my eyeliner, and smears on my upper lid. Paradoxically, it takes ages to get any on my eyelashes: I need four coats to get anything like a good coverage, and it still makes my lashes look short and sparse, which they aren't. I persevered with it for two weeks, as it can sometimes take a while for a new mascara to settle down, but there's no improvement. Obviously mascara is a very personal thing, but for me this one is an epic fail. Sorry, Sunday.