Great eyeliner, just not waterproof.

Best eyeliner I have ever tried, does not smudge, stay all day, I tried so many eyeliners from famous brands but this one really the best.

Let's start with the positives: the application is easy thanks to the shape of the felt tip and the wand. However the colour payoff is really not good, you have to swipe over the same spot multiple times and sometimes the product lifts when doing that leaving you with random patches. Also, it is absolutely not waterproof.

To begin with, this product has brilliant application and staying power, making it really easy to get a great line that lasts all day. I've repeat purchased this product maybe 6/7 times, and I'm always delighted, to begin with. However, the product runs out extremely quickly and can sometimes stick to the top lid. That said, I do keep going back because of the good value and the initial success (and also the fact that I am yet to find a better product despite trying several others).

I wear waterproof liquid eyeliner every day and thought this sounded ideal for me. It goes on easily and looks great - so far so good. Unfortunately, throughout the day it continually smudges onto my upper eyelid leaving black marks. I rub it away, a couple of hours later there are more marks. It was even worse when I sprayed setting spray on top - it smudged right away. Going back to MAC Liquidlast asap, that literally never budges. Guess I'll throw this away.