It is not a one swipe eye makeup remover. It's more like 10 cotton swabs later you have racoon eyes. I need to remove the rest with my Rodial dragon's blood cleansing water. Using this Sarah Chapman product on my eyes means I'm rubbing my eyelids wayyyy too many times than is healthy. Will not rebuy.

This didn´t work at all on my waterproof mascara (too faced "better than sex". A real disappointment!)

I'm almost finished with my first bottle, and am considering buying another. I wear waterproof mascara and with other eye makeup removers, it takes a considerable amount of effort to wipe it all off. This works more effortlessly, and seems to get a lot more product off with one cotton pad, instead of several. I'm sure there are several others on the market at a much lower price point that can do the job just as effectively, but this has a lot of great ingredients so you can also use it as an eye treatment.

I bought this to take off my favourite but very stubborn waterproof mascara. It was utterly useless. However, I am giving it an extra star for being a lovely eye treatment mask. Feels beautifully refreshing (but use another product to get your waterproof mascara off first).

I have very sensitive eyes, this cleanser takes all makeup off, waterproof included, without rubbing for hours, doesn’t cause watering and it actually makes leashes look healthier.