I got mine in the color rich brown, love the color and really long lasting! The only pencil that doesn’t smudge on my inner corner! Want to try more colors!

I like the colour and texture but it doesnt las long

I like the color. But first the liner was very smooth now it’s gone a bit hard and it’s difficult to use or make a sharp line. 

I love this eyeliner having previously purchased it. The reason I love it is that it is small, great for waterline and doesn’t transfer from upper to lower lash line which is rare. However! This purchase was broken, I think the gel slipped into the cap and then completely smudged the outer casing. So annoying and not makes me hesitate to buy again. Product is good though. 

I love love love this product. The colour payoff is amazing and it's easily blendable which is great for beginners. I have to remove a star because the product finishes too fast.