I would've gave it 5 stars if the color doesn't go off easily

Smooth and easy application, sustainable for hours on lips. A marvelous lip product.

I have a bunch of these and use them often. The formula is totally weightless, does not have perfume, the finish is beautiful, and not too dry matte - they even out the lip texture a bit. Not for the dryest lip day, but I don't think any matte formula is. They last pretty well and wear off so nicely that I don't need to worry. The pencil is super practical to use and stays clean and hygienic. The color selection is excellent, too, with a fabulous selection of easy-to-use everyday shades and a few nice pops of color. Dolce Vita is a lovely everyday shade, I have purchased it several times - probably the only lip product I have ever repurchased. Dragon Girl is an absolutely gorgeous, unique red - overall, reds are GREAT in this range with a plethora of undertones. Try Walkyrie for a slightly muted everyday red, I love that, too.

Long lasting and not dry on the lips. Toped it up with Nars dolce vita lip balm

This is an underrated gem! I bought the colour Valkyrie after I already had "do me baby" (hate the cringe-y name do), and it is a very comfortable, matte formula. the pencil is also very easy to use, and because it is a lip pencil and lipstick in one, it is fairly long lasting.