Only 4 stars since the refill package is a bit loose in the jar which I don’t like. But I do like the refill option and the eye cream is really nice. Great clean ingredients and after applying my under eye area looks softer, a bit blurred, less wrinkly (I am heading 50 and although not that much, I do have some) and more plumped. It is not fatty and sinks in well but a tiny bit stays ‘on top’ for a bit which I like since the concealer is much easier to apply and mix into your skin. The ingredients are good. Mostly used in the morning by me. I have quite dry skin and lack of moisture and this is definitely what my skin likes.