Very good mascara. It does what it claims. Unfortunately my lids are too oily and eyelashes long so I always had black residue on my lids. 

Thickens and lengthens, doesn't look clumpy and doesn't end up giving me panda eyes. It's the best mascara I've ever used and I've tried all the high end mascaras.

I've been looking for a mascara for a long time that doesn't smudge under the eyes and doesn't create a panda effect. this tubing mascara is amazing. It makes beautiful lashes and really doesn't smudge. I recommend

I found this mascara in the Cult Beauty Advent Calendar. It's very volumizing and gives a kind of disheveled look at the lashes. My mother asked me what mascara I was wearing because the lashes were thick... Beautiful and luxurious packaging

It does an okay job but nothing out of the ordinary if we consider the price