This balm is really too oily, does not emulsify, the skin remains very oily

I've tried many cleansing balms as a first cleanse before my gel cleanser to really soak off the make up. Somehow it came pretty separated in the tube and since it's a balm you can barely shake it to mix up again. When applied it doesn't emulsify and stays extremely thick and oily. So yes, it melts the makeup, but then doesn't flush off your face and you need to use a different cleanser to get this off of your face. After that you need a third cleanse to cleanse your face properly. I understand that there's no perfume in it, but the raw ingredients of this balm also smell not pleasant at all. Almost like play-do. Would not recommend this balm.