After years of trying many mascara, I finally found one that create the perfect volume without clogging. It's so good I offered it to my mum and all my sisters, they all love it. I am addicted.

I'm wondering if the previous review is supposed to be for Charlotte's other mascara. Honestly, if you want to use one of her mascaras, this is absolutely the one I'd recommend. It looks fine with one layer, then lovely and long and voluminous with the second and third layers. It can clump easily if you let it, but just work the brush to keep the lashes separated and you're good. Unless you like the clumpy look, of course! Minimal to no smudging for me, and I've already gone through two tubes (usually in hot/humid climates).

I was so excited to try this mascara, but was so disappointed because it is so pricey. I can find cheaper than this one that do the job even better. It curls nicely, but not enough volume and like any other cheap drug store mascara you can find out there. The bottle also is not so wow to me. Not going to repurchase.

This mascara is definitely the more natural look mascara. It's not as impactful as the full fat lashes. Great for just everyday office/work looks without the 'pow' eyes. I do like it as it separates the lashes well, didn't transfer or smudge. Removed easily. I like it but if you are after a very black and wow eyes, maybe not the best choice.

I am disappointed. It provides very natural fluffy and soft effect, BUT no length and no fullness even with 3 layers. Mascara terrybly smudged under my eyes after 3 hours of wearing! I thought it is due to my new eye cream, but today I have been wearing my usual mascara for 12 hours and it is still on my lashes. Sorry, Charlotte, but only one star.