I am unsure on this product. I bought the darkest colour as my eyebrows are naturally very dark. When applying the colour was showing very light and appeared to apply very smudged rather than fine lines. Don’t think I would repurchase. Although other brow products from benefit work better for me. 

I ordered this in shade 3.5 as that's the shade I have in the pencil, but it went on far darker and did not suit me. It also gets clogged up with foundation very quickly and stops working. You also have to hold it at the correct angle to keep the liquid flowing. Not a good design at all, will stick with the Benefit eyebrow pencil, which I love.

Best brow product I've used so far

This pen doesn't do anything good. It doesn't do precise lines or anything similar. With this pen you get very unnaturally colored eyebrows. A waste of money.