It’s smudges a little bit throughout the day but still a solid eyeliner 

Still looking for the perfect black pencil that stays put in the waterline… this is not it :(

I am just finished one bottle, this sleeping oil totally great. not greasy, absorb immediately after apply to face. super moisture. the next day my face is glowing.

This eyeliner is lovely when first put on, and applies easily and irritation free, and doesn't transfer at all on me, however it does fade to nothing after a few hours, and is not as pigmented as other eyeliners. Its perfect if you don't mind reapplying.

I'm new to tight-lining and in my 40's, so some make-up looks become a real challenge to achieve. I've tried with three or four different eye pencils but it's been transfer hell within half an hour to an hour. With all the good things about Anastasia products I gave this a whirl. First time out it was pretty solid for four or five hours, which wasn't a bad result compared to the others. Second time; it was transferring in half an hour to one of my lower lids. I'll give it a couple more tries but it's not as bulletproof as I'd hoped.