Forever searching for the perfect liner. Loved the matte NYX one but prefer a felt tip... first application this was amazing! Like insanely good and didn’t budge all day. Ever since each time I try to use it the product smudges everywhere..... if it touches my waterline it fills my eyeball with product.... maybe I have a dud? It ruins my eye look every time.

I have tried so many liquid eyeliners but I can finally say this is my favourite. It is so easy to use, really black and does not smudge! Love it so much :)

It's really black and it's very easy to use BUT it does not last throughout the day, nor it is waterproof. The few times I wore it, the tiniest drop of water would ruin it; nevermind accidentally touching it or putting your face against something - it literally just sticks to whatever it is you put your face against. ( I have normal to dry skin)

Be very careful with it! As soon as I bought it I found out that the cap was kind of not right and it ruined the tip! Because it is a brush tip it can be easily manipulated which can be a negative some times. Overall it is very black, you can get a very sharp wing but it isn't SO long lasting. It's just meh.

I have been through a whole host of eye liners in my time and this is the one I always come back to. It glides on like a dream and does not budge until you cleanse. The pen itself also doesn't dry out too quickly and has a super fine tip so you can get a very precise wing.