I bought a bunch of different eye pencils from Lord & Berry (including this one, the supreme liner and the Silk Kajol Kohl) and I have to say I like the supreme liner more than this. The pros of this pencil is that it is rather creamy therefore it is very easy to apply, especially to use to line the bottom of the eye. However, the pencil is quite thick, which is not ideal for creating a nice feline flick. In addition, it does take sometime to set before becoming smudge proof.