Smudges under eyes. Too clumpy. Big brush which gets too much product. I literally trashed it today

Glides beautifully onto your lashes and lengthens and thickens them magically. A must buy for those who like one product to do it all.

I've been on the hunt for a waterproof mascara that holds a curl on my long,stubbornly straight eyelashes. I need to use a heater curler and a mascara that will then hold.My holy grail,urban decay cannonball was discountued and I've bought so many and this works! It holds a curl, lengthens and gives a flutter fan effect. Yes it's hard to get off but, an oil based remover works like a charm.The only downside is the size of the brush, could be smaller as it is quite cumbersome. I tend to wipe the brush with a tissue before using and application is smoother.

Yes, this mascara does lengthen and volumize but I have found many faults with it. The wand is very rigid and so it's difficult to apply without getting black smudges on your eye lids. As for the waterproof quality: I took this mascara on a round-the-world trip and can testify that water won't make it run; however, this also makes it very hard to remove without heavy-duty balms. In addition, it tends to create smudges under my eyes just from a few hours of wearing. Would not recommend unless you want to look like a zombie.

I loved this mascara and I highly recommend it the only thing is the top came off so I could see all the mascara inside I didn't do anything to try break it but when I first got it it started to lift up but I didn't know what it was so I left it and then I took the mascara wand out and the lid came of with it exposing all the inside and it isn't fixable so I had to throw it away.