I had previously seen the mixed reviews on this mascara but being a big fan of Milk makeup, and deciding to listen to the positive reviews, I went ahead and picked this up. When I say I’ve never been so disappointed with a mascara, I don’t say it lightly. I knew from the minute I opened it and used it, it was going to be hard work. Thick, clumpy, almost like it was months old and had become very hard to work with? I applied to my eyelashes but it just stuck them together with huge clumps of product sticking. Even using an eyebrow brush to try and brush the product through, the fact is my eyelashes looked terrible. I would not recommend this product and don’t think it’s fit to be called a mascara, let alone be sold.

I've tried SO many mascaras and had high hopes for this one based on all the good reviews, but I found it to be truly awful. Problems for me: brush is way too big, gloopy spider lashes, lashes stick together, loads of mascara ends up on eyelids. The only plus is that the container feels nice, heavy and solid. Annoyed that I've completely wasted my money and I can't bear to just chuck it out.

This is an amazing mascara - really does lengthen and thicken my very straight lashes.I saw from other reviews that others says it smudges. I've never had that problem with it but I do set my foundation with a translucent powder around my eyes before I use mascara and that always does the trick.

Maybe I got a bad batch but this is the clumpiest mascara I think I've ever used, it's even worse than the cheapo ones from Boots that I'd use as a teen. There seems to be no stopper at the top so each time you take the wand out it brings a whole mass of product with it so you end up globbing it on your eyelashes. It also has fibres in it, I assume to add length and volume but along with everything else, it just makes for a really messy look. So disappointed because I've seen such amazing reviews and I like this brand. Just does not do it for me at all.

This was the first Milk Makeup purchase I bought and it definitely was my gateway to all things Milk Makeup-I have very thick straight long lashes and this is the first mascara that I was able to get the Va-VOOM look and have it still look natural! Yes, the fibers and the consistency make it extremely dense, but what I've learned from this mascara over the years wearing it (probably 5 years now) is that it's literally one full coat, and then a tiny bit extra power on the tips of the lashes and you're done! No need to reapply, and with my stubborn lashes if I want more pop later in the day I do a quick 3 second press with my curler and my lashes do not crunch and are never damaged. This formula is perfect for my eyes!