I have always struggled with concealers. I have slightly dark circles and dry under eyes...in my opinion this is way above the Tarte tapeshape. No colour correction needed...

My first impression I have nothing bad to say and normally I'm very picky about concealer. It is very thick yet blends beautifully. Does not crease a lot but yes agree that it's better to use it with undereye corrector if you have dark circles. I'm only a bit surprised with the shade. I ordered Meringue and it is super light and bright. If you like Shape Tape light Neutral than Meringue is way to light. For winter that's ok, but for summer I think Coconut Flakes will be perfect. I don't know how it last through out the day though because I did not wear it yet.

I have dry skin and didn't find this drying at all, though you have to be careful with how much you apply. You don't need much at all and this tube will last a lifetime (meaning it's not overpriced at all). I haven't done proper baking while wearing this so I can't say if it gets cakey or not on that aspect, but as I said you really don't have to apply much at all when using this.

This one is a catch! Really good concealer, in my opinion better than Shape-Tape. Light, but it covers everything.

I like this concealer but feel like the shade range needs to be better. A little also goes a long way and the overall look is beautiful and not cakey.