I have medium length lashes. What I enjoyed about this mascara is that it definitely gave the volume I was looking for and it did not get under my eyes. I like the way it looks when I put it on fresh. I also like it after a full day's wear. However, I don't quite get the formula, it is equally dry as it is wet. So applying this mascara is a day by day adventure, as sometimes a bit too much of the formula on the brush clumps my lashes and it is a workout to separate them. And sometimes the formula does not cling on my lashes at all and it is another workout to make it work. Not too much of a problem for me.

For me most mascaras get under my eyes after a few hours, this one stays put all day!! For me this one is absolutely the best so far! 

I don't understand the low rating. For me it's the best mascara so far. I always get compliments about my eyelashes when I use this one. I'm also fond of all the mascaras of Charlotte tilbury but I think I prefer hourglass

It's not that bad but it's not amazing either. It brushes the lashes well, but I expected more volume and definition. A little hard to wash away but if you have no issue rubbing your eyes, it's fine.

I used to exclusively use the Better Than Sex mascara from Too Faced (which I still enjoy), but when I tried this, I was shook. This mascara is, without a doubt, the best one I’ve used ever. It seperates my lashes so well and lengthens them a lot. It looks gorgeous! Would recommend this to everyone.