This mascara works well for me on its own and doesn't smudge throughout the day. But as others have mentioned I have some problems with the primer - it seems to be stuck lower on the brush so it doesn't get transferred on the lashes unless I try very hard.

Favourite mascara, hands down. The primer and mascara combo makes my lashes so long. Super flattering and always gives me compliments from people asking if my (average length) lashes are real.

In the last 10 years this is the only mascara I’ve repurchased once I ran out and I now make sure I always have backups. It gives me volume and length and doesn’t smudge or flake. It’s the only mascara I can wear on my lower lashes without any issues. 10/10 recommend!

this mascara is great but beware that if you try it you can't do without it anymore...I've been using it for 4 years: I've also tried other brands but none make your lashes as long and full as this mascara.

This mascara is it. I'm done searching for a better one! My lashes are few and very straight but she makes them pop, i love it!