Volumizing but this product does transfer after a few hours...

didn’t like this one the best, plus its hard to remove cause it’s water proof

This mascara is not waterproof as such. Most days I get slight smudges. It's also less impressive in giving length and volume than the non-waterproof version. Benefit is not cruelty-free - thus, in any case, I will be looking elsewhere for my mascaras from now on.

I haven't gotten the hang of this semi-waterproof mascara quite yet (sometimes it holds well and sometimes I get slight smudging), but the finish is beautiful and it really makes my lashes look both lengthened and volumized. I would not repurchase though, due to it not being cruelty-free.

it is good when I first applied it but when I went swimming it hurt my eyes very badly and was flaky, I do not think it is really waterproof